Thursday, February 12, 2009

Stimulus package and the “American” automobile industry

Will the stimulus package save the “American” automobile industry? Professors Jay Heizer and Barry Render write that the cost of a Pontiac LeMans breaks down this way:

“About $6,000 heads to South Korea for the auto’s assembly; $3,500 goes to Japan for engines, axles, and electronics; $1,500 goes to Germany for design; $800 goes to Taiwan, Singapore, and Japan for smaller parts; $500 heads to England for marketing; $100 goes to Ireland for information technology; and the rest, about $7,600, goes to GM and its US bankers, insurance agents, and attorneys.”

In other words, the LeMans is barely American at all.

So why are GM and Chysler coming to our US government with hat in hand? Why don’t they demand handouts from the governments of Korea or Ireland? For that matter, why aren’t Ireland and Taiwan stepping up to hand billions to GM?

Actually, the German government is opening talks with GM’s local subsidiary, Opel, and the talks might lead to a bailout. So I can’t in fairness go all righteously indignant about that.

But I can reasonably be snarky about this: GM wanted all this globalization that led to the bleeding away of American jobs. If they’re in trouble now, why don’t they whine gimme-gimme to their precious World Trade Organization? A fine thing, to use WTO to marginalize the Congress and sovereignty of the United States - and then tell Congress they might or might not pay on Tuesday for a hamburger today.

In 1971, I worked for General Motors as a Junior Mathematician. (Yes, you read that right.) Never have I met people so out of touch with ordinary Americans. They had plans to build a car with windows that couldn’t be opened – only a slot to pay tolls through. They put our orientation group on buses to move us to another building 40 yards away; we trainees looked at each other in disbelief. It astonishes me that it took them another thirty years to go bankrupt.

When Toyota and Nissan became the quality leaders, GM said what me worry, Americans will buy American cars just because they’re American cars, doesn’t matter if they’re not very good cars. And GM was right – for a while. You can draw many messages from this story, but one of them is: Americans have already given GM their bailout, and GM blew it. Time to pack it in, General Motors.

Sunday, January 25, 2009

Alan Watts was a hard act to follow, but I did alright.

Each year I’m invited to lecture to our Organizational Psychology students on material from The Conscious Manager: Zen for Decision Makers. The lectures are well-received and I have fun with them.

Psychology has always big at our university; Carl Rogers, Victor Frankl, and Abraham Maslow have been faculty members here.

After my last lecture, a faculty old-timer remarked to me, “You know, long ago Alan Watts argued pretty much the same point you just did, and in this very room.”

Wow. What a rush to be a part of that tradition.

Just wanted to share the feeling with you.

Saturday, January 24, 2009

Infrastructure 2.0: What will it look like?

“Web 2.0” means more interactivity, user-generated content, optimized search and cross-connections, free software, and fees for service. The term emphasizes the contrast with the first wave of web activity, called “content-push” or Web 1.0, really just an electronic form of old-style publishing, with some hyperlinks thrown in.

Tom Friedman uses “Car 2.0” to describe Better Place’s electric car cum business model in which consumers buy miles on swappable batteries recharged using clean energy.

Sustainability 1.0 was "It costs money to be green." Sustainability 2.0 is "We can make money being green."

President Obama is about to launch massive infrastructure projects for economic recovery. Governors of every state have lists of “shovel-ready” projects that will absorb billions of federal money, no problem.  But you can bet these projects are “Infrastructure 1.0.”

What will “Infrastructure 2.0” look like?

Like Car 2.0, Infra 2.0 will blend high technology with innovative business models, some involving public-private cooperation. Smart technology will be central to transforming the delivery of water, sewage, energy, telecomm, transportation, garbage disposal…

Look sharp, now, because if Obama doesn't spend the money in 2009, it won’t kick-start the economy.  If we spend it on more Infra 1.0, the economy will end up even farther behind the 8-ball, in the long run. We don’t yet know what Infra 2.0 is, but we’d better figure it out quick.

Hit the ‘comment’ button and tell me your vision of Infrastructure 2.0.

Monday, November 10, 2008

The meltdown is my fault

Joe Rightwing is still writing to newspapers, trying to blame the financial meltdown on the government.  Like many of his fellow letter writers, Joe condemns the 1977 Community Reinvestment Act, which pressured lenders to help low-income people buy houses, as a market distortion.  Without the CRA, Joe claims, the free market would have kept the economy as level as the Bonneville salt flats. 

This is the height of silliness, for many reasons.  First, the CRA did not force banks to give $300,000 mortgages to people who could only repay $100,000 loans.  What’s that you say, Joe? There are no more $100,000 houses? Tell ya what: The government never prevented builders from erecting cheap houses.  Builders don’t like to build them because they’re less profitable.  That’s the free market at work.

I mean, really, Joe, this is the kind of “devil made me do it” excuse we wouldn’t accept from a six-year-old.

Second, the economy is cyclical whether it’s regulated or not.

Third, the Enron scandal was a wake-up call, and Joe, you didn’t wake up, didn’t even stir an eyelash.  Six years later, Lehmann Brothers is gone too.  Joe, now that you’ve been smacked on both sides of your head, smell the coffee: The free market is good, but people abuse the free market.

Mortgage brokers knowingly sold loans to unqualified buyers. (Economists call this “adverse selection.”) Middlemen securitized bundles of loans, could not even begin to measure the risk of a bundle (nor, therefore, its value), pulled a value out of where the sun don’t shine, and sold it to Lehmann Bros., who, forgetting the business cycle, bought the whole mess, lock, stock and barrel.  If this ain’t abuse, beat me with a stick.

You don’t think regulation is needed, Joe? I quote Joel Bakan: "No one would seriously suggest that individuals should regulate themselves, that laws against murder, assault, and theft are unnecessary because people are socially responsible. Yet oddly, we are asked to believe that corporate persons… should be left free to govern themselves."

Joe, I’m sorry if I implied it’s only you whose been hit on the head.  We’ve both been smacked.  In fact, it was only a matter of time before somebody blamed business educators for this mess.  And now, Joe, some of your fellow letter-to-the-editor writers have snarkily noted that most of the free market abusers have… MBAs.

And they’re right.  Mea culpa, Joe.  I’m a professor, and my ex-students did this.

At the 2002 meeting of the AACSB, the agency that accredits business schools, I waited anxiously for its officials, or any faculty speakers, to mention the word “ethics.”  None did.  The only speaker at the three-day conference to bring up ethics was a luncheon presenter, the CEO of Tupperware.  (There you go, Joe, I’m not anti-business. I make a point to note that in the close wake of Enron, it was a businessman, not an academic, who first said something was amiss ethics-wise.)

AACSB’s 2008 meeting was similarly light on angst about the mortgage crisis.  But it was in Honolulu, where it’s difficult to get too worked up over anything.  A few months later, the INFORMS conference – the gathering of operations researchers – focused on technical reasons why the financial engineering models didn’t work.  Not on the ethics of using them when doing so was clearly inappropriate.

At least at the University of Chicago there’s some disagreement about whether to name the new economics research institute after Milton Friedman.  At least there’s that.

The upshot is that business faculty are not exactly hammering away at this in MBA classes. How can we prepare the next generation of business leaders if we do not make it clear in every accounting, finance, O.R., marketing, and strategy class that responsible users of the free market cannot tolerate certain behaviors?

University faculty cannot make students or graduates act ethically.  But if pressure to act ethically does not begin in b-school, it’s a lot less likely that it will begin later.  MBA graduates were the ultimate cause of this crisis, but business professors were the proximate cause.

Fellow faculty members, repeat after me, and make sure Joe hears you: “The meltdown is my fault.”

Sunday, November 9, 2008

What’s love got to do with it? California’s Prop 8

"The noblest motive is the public good." - Seal of the County of San Diego

Proposition 8, banning gay marriage, passed last week in California. I’m sorry it did. Here’s my view of the heart of the issue.

The public’s interest in marriage has two, and only two, pieces. Marriage is a vehicle for conserving capital – that is, for people to get themselves out of poverty or to keep themselves out of poverty – and it is a vehicle for the secure raising of children. These pieces foster a stable society with fewer people on welfare or in prison.

It seems clear that a lasting marriage can serve both pieces regardless of the spouses’ genders. 

A voter considering only the public interest, therefore, would have cast a ballot against Prop 8.  All other arguments, of which we heard many in the run-up to the election – love, hate, civil rights, homophobia – were red herrings. Or would be, if the only consideration were the public interest.

But it wasn’t. People are entitled to vote their fears and their intolerance, and they did, and they won. 

For someone aiming at the “heart” of the issue, I’ve been awfully analytic. What’s love got to do with it? I’m wary of letting love into the realm of public interest. Demagogues use love of family and love of country to swindle young people into going off to war.  Let’s leave love to individuals, and their hearts.

Wednesday, October 22, 2008

Crowds – Wisdom or Madness?

What are we to make of The Wisdom of Crowds (2005) by New Yorker business columnist James Surowiecki?  After all, we were brought up on Charles MacKay’s Extraordinary Popular Delusions and the Madness of Crowds. The two books are at odds with each other.

First published in 1841 and popular ever since, MacKay’s work has stood the test of time.  It introduced the notion of mob psychology, noting that cool rationality is much more likely to show itself in individuals – and disappear in larger groups. MacKay put forth the Dutch tulip bubble and the Salem witch hunts as examples.

Surowiecki uses contrary examples – including the Who Wants to Be a Millionaire audience polls – to show that crowdsourcing can work.  The idea has caught on.  Companies now crowdsource their new product development! (Look here and here for examples.)  

Well, MacKay and Surowiecki can’t both be right, can they?

The Founding Fathers distrusted crowds.  That’s why we live in a republic and not a pure democracy. The idea that crowds could be right seems to stem from John Brunner's 1975 novel Shockwave Rider and is widely implemented today in what economists call “prediction markets.” 

This somewhat interesting notion got a black eye in 2003 when DARPA rolled out its “Policy Analysis Market,” which appeared to allow anonymous people to bet on terrorist attacks. Widespread public disgust was the main result.

Moreover, if markets (that is, mobs) could predict, then a horse with nine-to-four odds at the track would actually win about four of every thirteen races against a similar field, and this is demonstrably not true. (The historical database for horse races is far vaster than any for 21st-century artificial predictive markets!) 

Did Surowiecki and the economists forget that Shockwave was a work of fiction? Ah, but careful readers see Surowiecki hedging his claim: "Under the right circumstances [emphasis added], groups are remarkably intelligent, and are often smarter than the smartest people in them."

What are the right circumstances? A French mathematician burdened by the name Marie Jean Antoine Nicolas de Caritat, marquis de Condorcet (1743–1794) proved that a large crowd is likely to be right about a simple yes-no question only if each individual in the crowd has a greater-than-even chance of getting it right.  That is, only experts should be polled.  Condorcet offers no advice on how to qualify experts. Or how to find them.

So, is it MacKay or Surowiecki?  To be sure, two heads are better than one.  And small work groups in an organization can outperform individuals. (We’ve all been through that tiresome demonstration on our HR training days.)  But two to six people ain’t a crowd…

There are two phases in every decision: divergence, which means generating alternatives, and convergence, in which all but one of the alternatives are cut away.  Crowds are good at divergent creation of ideas – the more the merrier – but when it comes to deciding (a word that means “cutting away”), I see no signs of mobs doing better than small groups or singles.

Just look at the bankers who rushed to buy securitized mortgage instruments, or voters in the 2004 presidential election. MacKay takes the day!

p.s. I’ve treated this subject in turgid academese, in a paper called “Change in Socio-Technical Systems: Researching the Multis, the Biggers, and the More Connecteds.”

Sunday, October 5, 2008

There’s a bailout someone's longin’ to see...

To the tune of Ella Fitzgerald's "Someone to Watch Over Me":

There’s a bailout someone's longin’ to see
Citibank... sure wants to be
The one for Wachovia

I'm a little lamb who’s borrowed heavily
Prompt payer of bills, sure tried to be
Now Hank Paulson walks all over me

(release)
Although he may not be the man some
Would expect to pay the ransom
To my house he carries the key

Won’t you tell him please to put on some speed
Follow my lead, oh, how I need
Someone to watch over me-ee 
and Wells Fargo - Wachovia.